I give these 5 solid stars for style and uniqueness, 3 stars for function. These are made with a soft, lightweight sweater-knit that's been patchworked together with a semi-stretchy top stitch, and herein lies the 3 stars. The sweater knit is stretchier than the top stitching, so if your legs are muscular, the knit will stretch over them but the top stitching will not and that can create a lumpy-ish look along the thigh. The thigh band is 11 inches across when pulled to the max, so if your legs are slim, you'll be loving these. They are about 33 inches long which I appreciate, but the lightweight knit does not hug the length of your leg so keeping you cute takes priority over keeping you warm. Don't get me wrong, I adore these, I just wanted to share some details because these are not your average warmers.